Bag of Randomness

Capture7sontheodometer

“Religions that grow are the ones that are hard-core in some way—they have something that differs sharply from the culture in which they operate. “That’s the problem with mainline Protestantism: It’s not different enough from mainstream America. Evangelicals have been able to pitch themselves as the alternative to mainstream culture.”

Stephen Prothero, a religion professor at Boston University
Article

This entry was posted in Personal. Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Bag of Randomness

  1. MamaToots says:

    I couldn't find WifeGeeding in the "eye" list anywhere! And, trust me, her dedication to teaching young children is VERY important!!

  2. Rev. Hart says:

    I disagree with this quote from Stephen Prothero. Evangelicalism in America is actually totally reflective of mainstream culture, not "countercultural" as Prothero suggests. On Sunday mornings, Evangelicals stare at jumbotrons, dress in trendy outfits, and observe rock bands performing songs; that all seems quite like American culture to me. Their venues are ever-larger, like sports arenas, and their campuses are designed like shopping malls or business parks–again, all exceedingly reflective of the culture around them.

    Mainline congregations, on the other hand, still embody the quiet, contemplative worship of generations ago. Their architecture hasn't changed in hundreds of years, nor has their hymnology or liturgy. In their steadiness, it seems to me, they are exceedingly NOT reflective of the always-changing culture around them.

    There is no "irony", as Prothero posits, in the growth of Evangelicalism in the U.S. They are growing (at least in size of each congregation) because they are offering a pathos and a theology which are synonymous with American Market Capitalism (i.e. a preoccupation with individual success and a pacification through entertainment).

    The Evangelical church may appear to be growing in numbers as it gathers by the thousands in state of the art arenas, but the overall numbers are actually falling too, just like the Mainline church. And in any case, I'm not convinced that the number of people involved is indicative of actual Christians involved. If we compare a Mainline congregation of 100 active members to an Evangelical congregation of 500 active members, we may find the same number of people who truly understand Christian theology.

    I've just opened about 15 cans of worms, so I welcome any disagreements gladly.

    🙂
    Grace and peace,
    Nathan

  3. jonathan says:

    The Reverend paints his theories with some broad strokes…

  4. Suzi says:

    Wow – I wasn't aware that Wiley Post, John Dos Passos, or Alice Walker had just one usable eye. Also – Thanks for the link (above) for the flight tracker. Am flying soon and have bookmarked it.

Comments are closed.